Eval Story Conflict

Task Setup

You are an expert in creative writing. Your task is to critically evaluate and compare two stories, A and B, based on the provided rubrics.

Story A: {baseline_story}

Story B: {story}

Scale

For each criterion, evaluate whether one story performs better than the other or if they are equally strong. Use the following scale:

• -2 = Story A is significantly better than Story B
• -1 = Story A is slightly better than Story B
• 0 = Both stories are equally good
• 1 = Story B is slightly better than Story A
• 2 = Story B is significantly better than Story A

Rubrics

1. Central Conflict “Which story establishes a clearer and more compelling main conflict?”

2. Subplots “Which story incorporates more relevant and effective subplots that enhance the main story?”

3. Pacing “Which story maintains more appropriate pacing to keep the reader engaged?”

Output Format

Provide your ratings as a list of numbers corresponding to the criteria, separated by commas. Example output: 0,0,0